The Spokesman
Three days after IRGC missiles destroyed Ukraine International Airlines Flight 752 and killed 176 people, government spokesman Ali Rabiei offered a remarkable defense: “The truth is, we didn’t lie. A lie means a deliberate fabrication of reality.”1
He said this after three days of categorical denial. After the regime’s civil aviation chief declared it “scientifically impossible” that a missile hit the plane. After state media published articles titled “Seven Reasons to Lie that a Missile Hit the Ukrainian Aircraft.” After bulldozers had already cleared the crash site. After passengers’ electronic devices had been opened and their memory components extracted.2
Rabiei’s statement was not a slip. It was the regime’s actual epistemological position: we did not lie, because we define lying differently than you do. When the Islamic Republic asks the world to trust its casualty claims from Minab — or from anywhere — this is the institution making the request. What follows is its track record.
The Ledger
Each entry follows the same format: what the regime claimed, what actually happened, how long the lie lasted, and how it was exposed. The pattern is the point.
1988: The Prison Massacres
Claim: Nothing happened. Death certificates listed fabricated causes of death — illness, wrong dates, wrong locations. Families received a bag of belongings and an instruction: do not speak about this.
Truth: Khomeini issued a secret fatwa ordering execution of political prisoners across at least 32 cities. Three-member “Death Commissions” — including twenty-seven-year-old Ebrahim Raisi — questioned prisoners and sent those who gave wrong answers to be hanged. An estimated 2,800 to 5,000 were killed. Bodies were buried in mass graves at Khavaran cemetery and Behesht Zahra.
Duration of denial: 28 years.
How exposed: Montazeri’s 2000 memoirs included protest letters. In August 2016, his son released a 40-minute audio recording of Montazeri confronting the Death Commission: “The greatest crime committed during the reign of the Islamic Republic, for which history will condemn us, has been committed by you.” Raisi and Pour-Mohammadi’s voices are clearly audible. In 2022, a Swedish court sentenced IRGC member Hamid Nouri to life imprisonment for his role — the first criminal conviction.
Aftermath: Intelligence Ministry took the recording offline within 24 hours. Ahmad Montazeri received a 21-year sentence. In 2009, authorities bulldozed Khavaran and planted trees. In August 2025, heavy machinery demolished another burial site. Iran secured Nouri’s release via prisoner exchange in 2024 — Amnesty called it “a stunning blow to survivors.”3
1992: The Mykonos Assassinations
Claim: Iran “categorically denied” involvement in the assassination of four Iranian Kurdish dissidents at the Mykonos restaurant in Berlin. Called the trial a “Zionist-Western conspiracy.”
Truth: Ordered by the “Committee for Special Affairs” at the highest levels of the Iranian state.
Duration of denial: Permanent (34 years).
How exposed: The Berlin Kammergericht verdict — after 247 court sessions, 170 witnesses, and three and a half years — explicitly named Supreme Leader Khamenei, President Rafsanjani, Foreign Minister Velayati, and Intelligence Minister Fallahian. The court found the killing was “part of the Islamic Republic’s official policy to eliminate political opponents abroad.” All EU member states recalled their ambassadors — an unprecedented action.4
1994: The AMIA Bombing
Claim: Iran had nothing to do with the bombing in Buenos Aires that killed 85 people. In 2024, Tehran Times characterized it as possible “‘self-harm’ of the Jews.”
Truth: Prosecutor Alberto Nisman’s eleven-year investigation led to Interpol red notices for six Iranian officials. Iran’s response was to promote the fugitives: Ahmad Vahidi became Defense Minister, then Interior Minister; Mohsen Rezaei became Vice President.
Duration of denial: 31 years.
How exposed: Nisman’s investigation. In April 2024, Argentina’s Federal Court formally declared Iran a “terrorist state.” In 2025, Argentina ordered an in absentia trial and the prosecutor requested an international arrest warrant for Khamenei. Nisman himself was found dead on January 18, 2015 — the day before he was to present evidence of a cover-up. A 2025 National Prosecutor’s Office report concluded he “was the victim of a homicide.”5
1998: The Chain Murders
Claim: When dissident intellectuals Dariush Forouhar and his wife Parvaneh Eskandari were stabbed to death — eleven and twenty-four knife wounds respectively — Khamenei immediately blamed Israel. The Intelligence Ministry later pinned blame on “rogue agents.”
Truth: Over 80 murders of dissident intellectuals conducted by the Intelligence Ministry under direct Supreme Leader authority.
How exposed: The designated “rogue agent,” Saeed Emami, conveniently died in prison — allegedly by drinking hair-removal cream. Nobel laureate Shirin Ebadi, the family’s attorney, said the suicide account was impossible. Investigative journalist Akbar Ganji traced the killings to the highest levels. Retaliation: Ganji’s editor Saeed Hajjarian was shot in the face and paralyzed for life.6
2009: The Green Movement
Claim: Up to three million protesters were “foreign-backed rioters” conducting a Western-orchestrated “velvet revolution.”
Truth: Basij militias and plainclothes agents attacked peaceful marchers with live ammunition. At Kahrizak detention center, multiple detainees died from torture.
The Neda test: Neda Agha-Soltan was shot in the chest on a Tehran street. The video was viewed worldwide. The regime produced four contradictory explanations: (1) killed by protesters themselves, (2) CIA responsible, (3) BBC/CNN fabricated the video, (4) staged death with fake blood. Eyewitnesses identified the killer as Basij militiaman Abbas Kargar Javid, who was heard saying “I did not mean to kill her.” He was never prosecuted.7
2019: Bloody Aban
Claim: The Supreme National Security Council dismissed casualty figures as “fake news” and “premeditated psychological warfare.” The regime never released comprehensive casualty figures.
Truth: The deadliest crackdown since 1979. Reuters — citing three interior ministry officials — reported approximately 1,500 killed, including seventeen teenagers and approximately 400 women. In Mahshahr, Revolutionary Guards encircled protesters in marshlands and killed 40 to 150 with DShK heavy machine guns.
Duration of denial: 5 weeks (until Reuters investigation).
How exposed: Reuters special investigation from interior ministry sources. Amnesty International independently documented 304 or more killed, including 23 children.8
2020: Flight PS752
Claim: Day 1: “technical failure” and “engine malfunction.” Day 2: “Scientifically, it is impossible that a missile hit the Ukrainian plane.” Day 3: Missile theory called “a lie” and “psychological operations.” State media published coordinated articles — “Seven Reasons to Lie,” “Five Reasons to Refute,” “10 Reasons to Reject.”
Truth: IRGC air defense fired two Tor-M1 surface-to-air missiles at the civilian airliner. 176 killed.
Duration of denial: 72 hours.
How exposed: US satellite data detected two heat signatures. Cellphone video on Telegram showed the moment of impact. NYT obtained high-resolution footage; Bellingcat geolocated it. Iran admitted on Day 4, claiming “human error.” Leaked audio revealed Foreign Minister Zarif had asked the Supreme National Security Council on January 10 whether Iran shot down the plane — and was told to reject the accusation. Black boxes were delayed seven months. In 2021, an Ontario court ruled the shootdown was intentional and constituted “terrorist activity.”
Aftermath: IRGC Aerospace Commander Hajizadeh — who said “I wished I was dead” — remains in his position.9
2022: Mahsa Amini
Claim: “Suffered heart attack at police station.” The Forensic Medicine Organization attributed death to “cerebral hypoxia” linked to a brain tumor operation at age eight. Khamenei’s personal doctor attempted to get cardiologists to falsify records certifying heart problems.
Truth: Hospital source: brain tissue “crushed after multiple blows to the head,” lungs filled with blood. Leaked CT scans — obtained by hacktivists — showed skull fracture, hemorrhage, and brain edema consistent with severe head trauma.
How exposed: Iran International reporting, leaked CT scans, 800 members of Iran’s Medical Council accusing the Council head of assisting the cover-up. The UN Fact-Finding Mission — examining 38,000 pieces of evidence and interviewing 281 victims and witnesses — concluded: “physical violence in custody led to Ms. Amini’s unlawful death” and the government “actively obfuscated the truth.”
Father’s response: “They are lying. She never had any medical conditions, she never had surgery.”10
2022: Nika Shakarami
Claim: Sixteen-year-old Nika committed suicide by jumping from a building.
Truth: A BBC investigation obtained a 322-page classified IRGC file. Three named agents arrested Nika while disguised as protesters. In a van, she was gagged with an officer’s socks, forced face-down, beaten with three batons and three tasers. One agent committed sexual assault. Her death certificate stated she died from “multiple injuries caused by blows with a hard object.” Her body was withheld for ten days. Her aunt and uncle were arrested and forced to recant on state television.
The counterfactual test: If the regime’s account were true, the body would not have been held for ten days. Her phone would not have been deleted from the prosecutor’s office. Her family would not have been arrested. The IRGC would not have produced a 322-page classified file describing her death at the hands of its own operatives.11
January 2026: “No Chaos”
Claim: State media reported “no news of any gathering or chaos in Tehran.” Published an “official list of 2,986 victims” — characterized by HRANA as “mostly unverifiable.” Attributed violence to “foreign agents” who “instructed protesters to shoot each other.”
Truth: Protests in over 400 cities across all 31 provinces. On the same day of “no chaos,” six Tehran hospitals recorded 217 protester deaths from live ammunition. The New York Times, citing Supreme National Security Council sources, reported orders were “to shoot to kill and to show no mercy.”
How exposed: Diaspora networks, smuggled Starlink connections, brief connectivity windows. HRANA’s verified named list documented 7,007 deaths as of February 23. A former Interior official revealed preparations beginning in 2022 — including “marking and identifying elevated locations for sniper deployment” and “training criminal elements to play the role of leaders in gatherings.”12
The Bot Network
Claim: Accounts posing as British users on X, posting anti-protest messaging.
Proof of Iranian control: A Cyabra investigation exposed 1,300 fake profiles. When the June 2025 strikes knocked out Iran’s power grid, all 1,300 accounts went silent simultaneously — for exactly sixteen days — then resumed with shifted messaging when power returned. The accounts were coordinated through the Basij’s MATNA and Shamsa subdivisions. The Institute for Strategic Dialogue documented a trilateral operation: approximately 800 Iranian-linked posts, 200 Russian-linked, and 300 Chinese-linked during the December 28 to January 17 period.13
The Pattern
Every entry follows an identical sequence: deny categorically, destroy evidence, blame foreign enemies, produce coordinated disinformation, admit only under irrefutable pressure, minimize what was admitted, punish those who exposed the truth, and promote those responsible.14
Montazeri’s son received twenty-one years for releasing the tape. Ganji’s editor was shot in the face. Nisman was murdered. The DIA analyst who flagged Baghuz was forced from his position. Meanwhile, Raisi became president, Vahidi became Interior Minister, and Hajizadeh kept his command.
The denial half-life is compressing — from twenty-eight years for the 1988 massacres to seventy-two hours for PS752 to real-time contradiction in 2026. Social media and diaspora networks are collapsing the window in which the regime can operate unchallenged. But the impulse is unchanged: lie first, assess later, punish anyone who reveals the truth.
The Score
No documented case exists in which the Islamic Republic’s initial account of a contested event was later vindicated by independent investigation. Not one.15
Initial reports in any crisis are unreliable — that is normal. Fog of war distorts early casualty counts everywhere. What is not normal is systematic, coordinated, months-long fabrication backed by evidence destruction, witness intimidation, and the promotion of those responsible.
Consider how you evaluate any institution that has lied to you repeatedly — a company, a government, a public figure. At some point the burden of proof shifts. The ledger speaks for itself. The next time a new claim emerges — from Minab or anywhere else — this is the institution making it, and this is its record.
This article is part of The Dead Children Calculus. For how the US targeting system works, see How Targeting Actually Works. For the game theory of looking away, see The Price of Looking Away.
Footnotes
-
Ali Rabiei, government spokesman, after PS752 admission. Full quote: “The truth is, we didn’t lie. A lie means a deliberate fabrication of reality.” ↩
-
PS752 denial sequence: Ali Abedzadeh “scientifically impossible” (Day 2), state media “Seven Reasons to Lie” articles, crash site bulldozed within hours, electronic device tampering documented by retired Toronto homicide detective. ↩
-
1988 prison massacres: 2,800-5,000 killed (Amnesty/HRW). Montazeri audio released August 9, 2016. Ahmad Montazeri: 21-year sentence. Nouri trial: 92 sessions, life imprisonment. Nouri released via prisoner exchange June 2024. Khavaran bulldozed 2009. Section 41 demolished August 2025. ↩
-
Mykonos: 4 Kurdish dissidents assassinated September 17, 1992. Berlin Kammergericht verdict April 10, 1997: 247 sessions, 170 witnesses, 3.5 years. Named Khamenei, Rafsanjani, Velayati, Fallahian. All EU ambassadors recalled. ↩
-
AMIA: 85 killed July 18, 1994. Nisman: 11-year investigation, found dead January 18, 2015. Argentina declared Iran “terrorist state” April 2024. In absentia trial ordered 2025. Tehran Times “‘self-harm’ of the Jews” (2024). ↩
-
Chain Murders: 80+ killed. Forouhar and Eskandari: 11 and 24 knife wounds. Emami died in prison. Hajjarian shot in face March 2000. ↩
-
Green Movement 2009: Neda Agha-Soltan shot in chest. Four contradictory regime explanations. Killer identified, never prosecuted. ↩
-
Bloody Aban: ~1,500 killed (Reuters, 3 interior ministry sources). DShK machine guns in Mahshahr. Regime never released casualty figures. Amnesty: 304+ killed including 23 children. ↩
-
PS752: 176 killed. Three days denial. Zarif told to reject accusation. Bulldozed crash site. Device tampering. Ontario court: intentional, “terrorist activity.” Hajizadeh remains in command. ↩
-
Mahsa Amini: hospital source vs. regime “heart attack” claim. Leaked CT: skull fracture, hemorrhage. UN FFM: 38,000 evidence items, 281 victims/witnesses. “Physical violence in custody led to Ms. Amini’s unlawful death.” ↩
-
Nika Shakarami: 322-page IRGC classified file obtained by BBC. Three named agents. Sexual assault, beating death. Body withheld 10 days. Aunt and uncle arrested. ↩
-
January 2026: “no chaos” claim vs. 217 hospital deaths same day. NYT: “shoot to kill and show no mercy.” HRANA: 7,007 confirmed named deaths. Former Interior official: sniper positions pre-planned starting 2022. ↩
-
1,300 fake profiles exposed by Cyabra. 16-day simultaneous silence during power outage. MATNA and Shamsa subdivisions. ISD: trilateral operation (800 Iranian, 200 Russian, 300 Chinese posts). Sources: Times of Israel, ISD, FDD. ↩
-
Eight-step denial pattern identified across all domains: deny, destroy evidence, blame foreign enemies, produce disinformation, admit under pressure, minimize, punish exposers, promote perpetrators. ↩
-
“No documented case exists” — based on systematic review of 25+ major contested events spanning 1979-2026. Every initial regime account contradicted by subsequent independent investigation. ↩